🏙️ Community Marketing: Building Tribes Around Your Brand

This issue of Marketing Machine is brought to you by…. Marketing Machine! 🚀

if you haven’t heard, we’re growing up around here.

We’re launching a paid support structure and a book. Don’t worry, the free version will continue.

But if you upgrade you’ll help the project grow. If you stick around for 3 months you’ll even get a copy of the book.

You can also just pre-order the book, which will be a compact version of everything we’ve learned over 20 years of machine building.

Traditional marketing focuses on broadcasting messages to audiences, but community marketing creates spaces where customers connect with each other around shared interests, values, and experiences with your brand. Instead of simply promoting products, community marketing builds lasting relationships that turn customers into advocates, collaborators, and evangelists.

Community marketing goes beyond standard customer engagement by creating environments where people form genuine connections with each other and your brand. These communities become self-sustaining ecosystems where members share experiences, solve problems together, and develop deeper relationships with your products or services.

The fundamental difference between audience marketing and community marketing lies in the relationships formed. Audiences consume content passively, while communities actively participate, contribute, and support each other. This shift from one-to-many communication to many-to-many interaction creates exponentially more value for both brands and customers.

Key characteristics of successful brand communities include:

Shared Purpose: Members unite around common goals, interests, or values that extend beyond just purchasing your products.

Member-to-Member Value: Community members help each other, share knowledge, and create value independently of brand intervention.

Ongoing Engagement: Regular, sustained interaction rather than sporadic campaign-driven participation.

User-Generated Content: Members create and share content that adds value for other community members.

Brand Advocacy: Community members naturally promote your brand through word-of-mouth and social sharing.

Building successful brand communities requires strategic planning, consistent nurturing, and genuine commitment to serving community members' interests beyond product promotion.

The foundation begins with defining community purpose beyond product promotion. The most successful communities center around helping members achieve specific goals, learn new skills, or connect with like-minded individuals. This purpose must align with clearly articulated values that guide community behavior and decision-making.

Platform Selection: Choose platforms where your target audience naturally gathers and feels comfortable engaging - Facebook Groups, Discord servers, LinkedIn communities, or specialized community platforms.

Initial Momentum: Launch with valuable content that demonstrates member value, recruit passionate early members who demonstrate strong brand affinity, and facilitate introductions between members.

Sustainable Growth: Encourage member-led content creation, develop recognition systems for valuable contributors, and provide access to company experts or exclusive information.

When possible, create opportunities for online community members to meet in person through events or meetups, and organize collaborative projects where members work together toward common goals.

User-generated content serves as both a driver of community engagement and a valuable marketing asset. When community members create and share content, they invest more deeply in the community while providing authentic marketing material.

Encouraging Content Creation: Make sharing effortless through simple tools and templates, offer regular prompts and challenges, establish different content categories from reviews to personal stories, and engage meaningfully with contributions through comments and feedback.

Content Quality and Amplification: Balance maintaining standards with allowing authentic expression, identify and promote high-quality content to inspire others, and help members improve through feedback and mentorship. Share compelling content across your marketing channels with proper attribution, partner with active members on larger projects, organize content competitions, and regularly spotlight member achievements.

Sustained engagement requires strategic facilitation through discussion-generating questions, regular themes or focuses, and connecting members with similar interests. Provide ongoing value through educational webinars and tutorials, exclusive access to products or information, member-led sessions, and expert Q&A opportunities.

Building deeper relationships involves facilitating subgroups for specific interests, encouraging personal storytelling, organizing collaborative initiatives, and connecting experienced members with newcomers through mentorship programs.

Effective community measurement goes beyond vanity metrics to assess genuine engagement, member satisfaction, and business impact.

Community Health Metrics: Track active participation rates rather than passive consumption, measure member retention patterns, assess content quality through engagement and feedback, monitor member-to-member interactions, and track response times for community questions.

Engagement Depth: Measure repeat participation over time, track cross-platform activity with your brand, monitor referral generation from existing members, analyze content sharing outside the community, and assess time spent in the community.

Business Impact: Compare lifetime value of community versus non-community customers, analyze purchase behavior differences, measure support cost reductions through peer assistance, assess product feedback quality, and track brand advocacy generation.

Qualitative Assessment: Conduct regular member satisfaction surveys, document success stories, monitor community sentiment, and track how member feedback influences business decisions.

Selection Criteria: Choose based on audience preferences, required features, moderation capabilities, integration options, and scalability needs.

Popular Options: Facebook Groups offer broad reach and familiar experience, Discord provides real-time communication ideal for engaged communities, LinkedIn Groups serve professional networking needs, while dedicated platforms like Circle offer advanced features and customization.

Successful community marketing requires consistent application of proven principles and ongoing measurement of both community health and business impact.

Member-First Mindset: Prioritize community member interests and value creation over direct promotional opportunities.

Authentic Participation: Contribute genuinely to community discussions instead of using communities purely as marketing channels.

Long-Term Vision: Build communities with sustainable strategies rather than short-term campaign mentalities.

Value Before Promotion: Establish strong benefit delivery before introducing promotional content or sales-focused initiatives.

Community Empowerment: Enable members to take leadership roles and contribute to community development.

Community Vitality: Track active participation rates, member retention, and quality of member-generated content and discussions.

Business Impact: Monitor how community participation affects customer behavior, lifetime value, and advocacy generation.

Member Satisfaction: Regularly assess member satisfaction, perceived value, and suggestions for improvement.

Growth Quality: Measure sustainable growth in engaged members rather than just total membership numbers.

Community marketing represents a fundamental shift from traditional broadcast marketing toward relationship-based engagement that creates lasting value for both brands and customers. As consumers increasingly seek authentic connections and peer-to-peer support, brand communities will become even more important for building loyalty and driving growth.

The most successful community marketing initiatives focus on creating genuine benefit for members beyond product promotion. Brands that invest in building thriving communities while measuring both community health and business impact will develop stronger customer relationships and achieve sustainable competitive advantages.

As community platforms and tools continue to evolve, marketers must stay focused on fundamental community-building principles while adapting to new technologies and member expectations. The future belongs to brands that can create communities where members genuinely want to participate, contribute, and advocate for both the community and the brand.

Oh hello. It’s us again. {m}

Marketing Machine. Here’s some more about the book 👇

If you didn’t catch it in the ad slot above, we’re launching a paid tier and a book. Because this is Marketing Machine, they’re intertwined. Upgrade to support us and to get all the content as we make it.

You’ll get a copy of the book if you stick around.

You can also just pre-order a copy of the book.

Either way, we’ll send you a beautiful hardcover when it’s ready. (Early 2026)

You can get both here.

Discord Marketing Strategies Proven To Work [20 min read]

Discord has evolved from a gaming-focused platform to a powerful marketing tool with over 200 million active monthly users, offering brands access to highly engaged communities across diverse demographics. The most effective Discord marketing strategy centers on building dedicated servers that function as exclusive communities where brands can foster direct relationships with consumers through personalized channels and exclusive experiences. Success on the platform requires specific tactics tailored to Discord's unique environment, including leveraging bots, hosting interactive events, encouraging user-generated content, and focusing on genuine community engagement rather than viral content strategies used on algorithm-driven platforms.

How A Community Marketing Strategy Can Breathe Life Into Your Local Business [5 min read]

Local businesses should optimize their websites and social media presence with location-specific keywords, landmarks, and regional terms to improve their visibility in local searches and create a strong digital foundation. They must then engage consistently with their community by creating interactive content, running promotions, and actively participating with other local accounts to build meaningful relationships both online and offline. Finally, successful local community marketing requires bridging the digital and physical worlds by hosting regular in-person events, partnering with local organizations, and creating opportunities for online community members to connect face-to-face at the business location.

That's it for this week! See you Friday. 😎

Forwarded this email? Click here to subscribe. Don't want to miss out? Make sure to whitelist our email! 🥳😉

Something else you’d like to see here? Hit reply and let us know what you think. 🧠 Or smash a button on our feedback poll!

✌️ Team Marketing Machine

For real tho, if you’ve made it this far, help us go reader supported. Here’s a button: